|
July 2, 2004, Volume 1, Number
9
DEMOCRACY
DIGEST
The Weekly Bulletin of the Transatlantic
Democracy Network
ISSUES
The
Summer Summits: Friends Again?
Differences
did arise, but the two transatlantic summit meetings held over
the past week produced little evidence that leaders on either
side of the ocean see cooperation to encourage democracy
elsewhere as a discredited or unrealistic purpose. Both the
EU-US Summit at Ireland's Drumoland Castle on June 25-26 and
the NATO Summit in Istanbul on June 28-29 produced an array of
statements and agreements that, if carried out, could
re-invigorate efforts by the transatlantic powers to assist
others who seek their own paths to more open societies and
more representative governments.
A joint statement
at the US-EU Summit promised "close cooperation to diminish
the underlying conditions that terrorists can seize to recruit
and exploit to their advantage. By promoting democracy,
development, good governance, justice, increased trade and
freedom, we can help end dictatorship and extremism that bring
millions of people to misery and bring danger to our own
people." So, despite all its difficulties, democratic reform
-- not simply improved police methods -- remains central to
the fight against terrorism.
The EU also welcomed
the transition to a new government in Iraq, and stated that
"The EU will launch dialogue with the Iraqi Interim Government
and society and stands ready to prioritise support for the
political process and elections, consider further support for
the rule of law and civil administration in Iraq, use its
relations with Iraq's neighbours to encourage positive
engagement and regional support for political and economic
reconstruction...."
In a separate statement
following the general lines of last month's G8 declaration on
the Broader Middle East, US and EU leaders pledged "to work
with each other in concrete areas to support democratic
development and the fullest possible participation by all
citizens through programs to strengthen civil society and
promote democratic norms and institutions" throughout the
region. They also noted that "lasting reform must come from
within...." And they adopted a strong statement of concern
about the situation in Sudan (see below.)
The NATO meeting in Istanbul produced some disagreements
between the US and Britain on on one hand and France in the
other. But despite these, the communique'
reminds us "The recent enlargements of NATO and the European
Union are a major step towards a Europe whole and free, and a
strong confirmation that our organisations share common values
and strategic interests."
The conflict of greatest interest was the French
insistence that additional NATO troops not be deployed
throughout Afganistan to help establish security in the period
leading up to next September's election. NATO troops are now
virtually all in Kabul, and Afghan President Hamid Karzai came
to Istanbul to beg the Alliance to help him contain the potent
mix of terrorists and warlords that could disrupt this
summer's critical electoral process. The final communique'
also included some touches that in another era hardboiled
security strategists might have thought gratuitous: a
condemnation of trafficing in persons, a nudge about human
rights in Libya, and a pointed comment on the need for Ukraine
to respect democratic processes.
G8
to Launch DAD At
last month's G8 summit in Sea Island leaders of the world's
developed democracies committed themselves to a new process of
consultation about democratic reform in the Broader Middle
East. As the G8 communique' puts
it, they will "establish with willing partners in the region a
Democracy Assistance Dialogue (DAD) that will ...bring
together in a collaborative and transparent environment
willing governments, civil society groups and other
organizations from G-8, EU and others, and countries in the
region to:
- Coordinate and share information and lessons learned on
democracy programs in the region, taking into account the
importance of local ownership and each country's particular
circumstances;
- Work to enhance existing democracy programs or initiate
new programs;
- Provide opportunities for participants to develop joint
activities, including twinning projects;
- Promote and strengthen democratic institutions and
processes, as well as capacity-building;
- Foster exchanges with civil society groups and other
organizations working on programs in the region."
Discussions are now underway about how this initiative can
be appropriately launched. The US will be the first country to
hold the rotating chair of the Dialogue, and some have
suggesting a first meeting toward the end of this year.
Democracy Digest will keep readers informed.
The
State of the Transatlantic Relationship
The
condition of the transatlantic relationship is generating a
flurry of studies and commentary. In a new book, Free
World: Why a Crisis of the West Reveals the Opportunity of our
Time, Timothy Garton Ash warns against "Euro-Gaullist
fantasies" that envision Europe as a superpower rival to the
US. He argues instead for a new transatlantic partnership that
can strengthen democracy and development, and that will
present an attractive alternative strategy for American
unilateralists. He also recommends that citizens lobby Western
governments to provide more resources to democracy promotion
groups like the US National Endowment for Democracy, the UK's
Westminster Foundation and the German party foundations. Ash
thinks that a caucus of democracies at the UN -- such as that
advocated by supporters of the Community of Democracies --
could become "the mother of all caucuses."
An Arab world "plagued by dictatorship and backwardness"
provides an urgent need for transatlantic cooperation, Ash
argues in the British magazine Prospect.
While US pressure on the likes of Saudi Arabia and Egypt is
indispensable, Europe's proximity and vulnerability make a
European role in the Middle East even more necessary. By
opening negotiations for Turkish membership, the European
Union "could signal to the whole wider middle east that a
Muslim country with an Islamist government can be accepted as
part of the liberal democratic West" (or, as Ash sometimes
puts it,"post-West").
A number of others examine this subject by different
lights. The New York Times's
Richard Bernstein suggests that the trans-Atlantic divide
is "growing ever deeper," and insists that the behavior of Abu
Ghraib guards has "shaken the sense of moral solidarity that
has always been at the core of the trans-Atlantic alliance."
Reginald
Dale, editor-in-chief of European Affairs and a
fellow of Stanford University's Hoover Institution, challenges
the notion that the European Union is excessively inward
looking, and preoccupied with economic and monetary matters,
enlargement or its new constitution. "Recent U.S.-European
tensions are deeply rooted in the ambitions of a more outward
looking EU to play a bigger role on the world stage," he says.
"The serious efforts now being made by both sides to reinvent
trans-Atlantic relations aim to fashion a new, joint approach
to global problems, especially the Middle East."
It is sometimes said disdainfully that Europe "speaks
softly and carries a big carrot." But Parag
Khanna, senior research analyst in governance at the
Washington-based Brookings Institution, looks approvingly at
an EU approach that stresses "soft power," conditionality and
economic incentives to promote democratic change. He argues
that, "By exporting the EU legal code -- the acquis
communitaire -- and deploying massive economic subsidies
and incentives, Europe has managed to embrace unstable nations
emerging from Soviet occupation, fostering democratic
consolidation all the way to Russia's border."
Spain's new prime minister, Jose
Luis Rodriguez Zapatero, sees differences between North
America and Latin America that are as important to him as
Donald Rumsfeld's distinction between "New Europe" and "Old
Europe." Because of the EU's contribution to democratizing
Spain, says Zapatero. "First comes Europe, then our historic
ties with Latin America and the Mediterranean, and after that
come trans-Atlantic relations."
Pavol
Demes, former Slovak foreign minister and currently head
of the central and east European division of the German
Marshall Fund, sees it from a very different perspective.
"Almost all the leading think tanks helping develop democracy
here have been from America", he explains. "Under communism,
the dissidents were directly or indirectly supported by the
United States. We are European, sure, but we really value our
relationship with America."
Several European politicians have recently expressed
skepticism about the EU's ability to go it alone, or to effect
change simply through soft power. Europe has been unable to
solve such problems as democratization in Belarus, conflict in
the Dnestr enclave in Moldova, or the continuing crises in
Kosovo, Albania, and Macedonia, notes Poland's president
Aleksander Kwasniewski. "You can't talk of European foreign
policy and at the same time be helpless in the face of
problems that are much smaller than those of Iraq,
Afghanistan, or the Israeli-Palestinian conflict," he recently
told Gazeta Wyborcza. [Polish News Bulletin, May 6,
subscribers only.]
The sometimes provocative former French Prime Minister and
Socialist Party leader Michael
Rocard bluntly challenges rival French leaders: Europe, he
declares, "far from being a single nation in the process of
formation...is only a space of proximity governed by
democratic norms and a shared rule of law." Rocard explains
that "While the mission of this space may not be enough to
shift the balance in world affairs, it can help spread peace,
respect for human rights, and efficient and respected rules
governing global commerce." "Experience has spoken," he
concludes, "We have to abandon today the dream of federal
Europe as a counterpoint to the United States....the majority
of Europeans don't want this."
Serbian
Vote Brings Relief to Allies
A
pro-democracy reformer who will seek closer ties with the EU
and the US won a decisive victory over an ultra-nationalist
supporter of Slobodan Milosevic in last Sunday's elections for
the presidency of Serbia. According to election
officials, Boris Tadic, a former defense minister,
defeated Tomislav Nikolic of the extremist Radical party by
53.5% to 45%. Previous rounds of balloting had been declared
invalid because of low turn-out.
The Serbian vote had been watched with great concern by the
Atlantic democracies and others. The substantial presence of
election monitors from the Organization for Security and
Cooperation in Europe (OSCE) contributed to an orderly
election process. The OSCE Chairman-in-Office, Bulgarian
Foreign Minister Solomon
Passy, welcomed the outcome: "We are confident that the
election of the new President will contribute to the
consolidation and stabilization of democratic institutions in
Serbia and strengthen the country's reformist course and
European orientation."
The Serbian results eased concerns of those at this week's
NATO Summit who agreed to replace NATO's Stabilisation Force
(SFOR) in neighboring Bosnia and Herzegovina with a new EU-led
peacekeeping force (EUFOR) by the end of 2004. A cautionary
report by the International Crisis Group had noted that
the situation in Bosnia-Herzegovina was still rocky, and that
there are "some realistic doubts about whether the
cash-strapped and far-from-integrated armies of the EU member
states are capable of meeting these challenges." The ICG
report charged that the motives for the hand-over from NATO to
the EU "have less to do with the real security situation in
that country than with EU eagerness to bolster its credibility
as a security actor and US desire to declare at least one of
its long-term military deployments successfully over."
Sudan:
Democracy and Famine US
Secretary of State Colin Powell and UN Secretary General Kofi
Annan are both visiting Sudan this week to observe the grim
effects of ethnic cleansing in Darfur province. It is widely
acknowledged that the Janjaweed militias that viciously attack
the villages of African tribes in the region operate with the
support and encouragement of the Sudanese government.
The recurrent crises in Sudan are often looked upon as
humanitarian emergencies, and the role of government in
promoting displacement and famine is dealt with ...
diplomatically. But a peace agreement between the Government
of Sudan and the southern Sudan Peoples' Liberation Movement
now it its final stages of negotiation offers the possibility
that Sudan may soon be more open to freedom of expression and
association, and that elections will take place that can
effect the character of government. Proponents of "directed
development" sometimes scoff that "you can't eat democracy."
Sudan's experience is a demonstration of Nobel Prize winner Amartra
Sen's thesis in The Journal of Democracy that "in
the terrible history of famines in the world, no substantial
famine has ever occurred in any independent and democratic
country with a relatively free press."
Concern Shadows
the Ukrainian Elections Viktor Yushchenko,
former Prime Minister and one-time head of Ukraine's central
bank, announced on Monday that he will run as a reform
candidate to replace President Leonid Kuchma in the national
elections scheduled for October 31st. His announcement
followed a decision last week by Ukraine's parliamentary
majority to nominate incumbent Prime Minister Viktor
Yanukovich as its candidate.
Says Anders
Aslund, the Swedish authority on the post-Soviet world,
"Hardly anybody doubts that the presidential election on
October 31 will take place and be a watershed in modern
Ukrainian history."
The Kuchma government is accused by many of implication in
the deaths and disappearances of important journalists and
opposition figures, and of efforts to undermine the
independent media. Ukraine has sent troops to Iraq, and in
other ways cooperates with th US in the Mediterranean and the
Middle East -- a relationship that some fear could tempt the
US to go easy on the ruling group if complaints arise about
election abuses. This could oblige Europeans to take a lead
role in pressing for free and fair elections in Ukraine. On
June 25 NATO Secretary General Jaap
de Hoop Scheffer pointedly called on the Ukrainian
government to respect democratic values: "We all know what it
means -- no persecution of the media, conducting free and fair
elections, and the superiority of law and freedom of speech."
Engaging
the Debate Within Islam A
recent study
by Cheryl Bernard of the National Security Research Division
of the RAND Corporation, a major U.S. think tank, argues that
encouraging moderate and peaceful trends within the Islamic
world will require "a finely grained understanding of the
ongoing ideological struggle within Islam to identify
appropriate partners and set realistic goals." Bernard sees
four distinct currents in contemporary Islamic thought:
fundamentalists, modernists, traditionalists and secularists.
"The modernists and secularists are closest to the West in
terms of values and policies," she contends. "However, they
are generally in a weaker position than the other groups,
lacking powerful backing, financial resources, an effective
infrastructure, and a public platform. The secularists,
besides sometimes being unacceptable as allies on the basis of
their broader ideological affiliation, also have trouble
addressing the traditional sector of an Islamic audience.
Traditional orthodox Islam contains democratic elements that
can be used to counter the repressive, authoritarian Islam of
the fundamentalists, but it is not suited to be the primary
vehicle of democratic Islam. That role falls to the Islamic
modernists, whose effectiveness, however, has been limited by
a number of constraints ...." The 88-page paper
elaborates this argument.
Egyptian Human
Rights NGOs Study New Government Council Some 170
participants gathered on June 26-27 to consider how
non-governmental human rights organizations should relate to
the National Council for Human Rights established by the
Egyptian government under the leadership of former UN
Secretary-General Boutros Boutros-Gali. Some Egyptian human
rights activists have questioned whether this
government-created group could be considered "an attempt to
constrict civil society and human rights organizations" that
operate independently of the government.
The June meeting was organized by the Arab Program for
Human Rights Activists in Cairo. According to a June 28
press release, participants in this meeting agreed that:
- civil society society organizations should be freed from
restrictions imposed by Association Law No. 84 of 2002;
- the official National Council should be reconstituted on
a democratic basis so that all elements of society can
participate;
- the National Council should be assured independence and
required to operate with transparency.
The NGO group also agreed to continue its monitoring and
dialogue regarding future operations of the National Council.
INFORMATION
Dutch Presidency of the European
Union Website The website of the Dutch Presidency
of the European Union is now online. The website contains
information about the Dutch Presidency, including its
priorities, and a calendar of meetings and events and
information on EU policy issues, member states and candidate
countries. Policy documents relating to the various Council
meetings and summits will also be published on the site, and
updated daily.
VACANCIES
Foreign
Policy Association Job Board For an excellent and
extensive listing of positions available in the international
affairs field, see this site
maintained by the Foreign Policy Association.
The
Asia Foundation Democracy and Civil Society: Taiwan
The Asia Foundation seeks a Senior Program Manager
required to design and implement projects related to Taiwan's
democratic consolidation and development of domestic civil
society; produce periodic analyses of Taiwan's democratization
and civil society development; prepares proposals and reports
for these projects; and coordinate with civil society
organizations in Taiwan. Contact: Sue Su - Phone: (886-2)
2506-1174 or mailto:suesu@afit.org.tw.
Apply by: July 31, 2004
National Endowment for
Democracy Interns The NED seeks interns for its
International Forum for Democratic Studies, Reagan-Fascell
Fellowship, and Journal of Democracy. For further details
contact: Melissa Aten: Phone: 202-293-0300, extension 665 or
matilto:melissa@ned.org.
Apply by: July 15, 2004.
FORTHCOMING EVENTS
July, 4-6, The Hague, the Netherlands "Enhancing the
European profile in Democracy Assistance"
Conference Democracy AGENDA –- the Alliance for
Generating a European Network for Democracy Assistance -– has
confirmed several important speakers for their forthcoming
conference,
"Enhancing the European profile in Democracy Assistance."
Dutch Prime Minister Jan Peter Balkenende will join Madeleine
Albright, former US Secretary of State and president of the
National Democratic Institute, in addressing the conference in
The Hague, Netherlands. Other speakers include Lord Dahrendorf
of the British House of Lords, Adrian Severin, president of
the OSCE and former minister of state in Romania), Mamphela
Ramphele, Managing Director of the World Bank), Miguel Angel
Rodriguez (former President of Costa Rica) and Agnes Van
Ardenne, the Dutch Minister of International Cooperation.
The event is hosted by the Institute for Multiparty
Democracy, parallel to the Dutch presidency of the
European Union. The conference is prepared by a European wide
steering committee, containing the German Friedrich Ebert Stiftung, the
British Westminster Foundation
for Democracy, the French Fondation Jean Jaures
and the Swedish Centre
Party International Department
Netherlands Institute for Multiparty Democracy, IMD Office,
Korte Vijverberg 2, NL-2513 AB The Hague, tel: +31 70 3115464,
fax: +31 70 3115465, e-mail: info@nimd.org, web site: http://www.nimd.org/
July 7-10, Cascais, Portugal Conference on
Europe and the Trans-Atlantic Relationship A
conference wil be held at the Palácio dos Condes de Castro
Guimarães in Cascais, Portugal, organized by the Institute for
Political Studies of the Portuguese Catholic University in
association with the Harvard Summer Program, the Boston
College Summer Program and Wyzsza Szkola
Biznesu-National-Louis University of Poland. Speakers include
the German Marshall Fund's Craig Kennedy, Josef Joffe, Editor
of Die Zeit, French Parliamentarian Pierre Lellouche,
William Kristol of The Weekly Standard, Raymond Plant
of King's College, Oxford, and Democracy Digest's Penn
Kemble of Freedom House. The closing session will be addressed
by José Manuel Durão Barroso, the Prime Minister of Portugal.
The conference is convened by João Carlos Espada, editor of
Nova Cidadania and Director of the Catholic
University's Political Studies Institute, Journal of
Democracy editor Marc F. Plattner and Adam Wolfson, editor
of the Washington-based Public Interest magazine.
Further details and information about registration are
available from: Instituto de
Estudos Políticos da Universidade Católica Portuguesa
Palma de Cima, 1649-023, Lisbon – Portugal Tel. (351)
21-721-4129 Fax (351) 21-727-1836 E-Mail: mailto:imoreira@iep.ucp.pt
July 8, 2004, 8:00 am to 1:30 pm, Washington, DC, Hudson
Institute & Formosa Foundation "The Triangular
Relationship: the U.S., Taiwan and China" The speakers
include: Rand Fishbein, Fishbein & Associates; John
Tkacik, The Heritage Foundation; Bill Gertz, The Washington
Times; Charles Horner, Hudson Institute; Ross Munro, Center
for Security Studies; Derek Mitchell, CSIS; Jeffrey Bell,
Capitol City Partners; Constantine Menges, Hudson Institute;
and Li Pei Wu, Formosa Foundation. The conference will be held
at the Hudson Institute, 1015 18th Street, NW, Suite 300
Washington, DC. Space is limited. Please RSVP by July 6. For
more information, or to RSVP for this event, please contact Hudson Institute at
202-223-7770 or email RSVP@hudsondc.org.
July 13, 2004, 3:30-5:30 pm, Washington, DC, Woodrow Wilson Center "A
Billion Ballots for Democracy: Election Year in
Indonesia." The scheduled speakers at this event are
Muhammad Qodari,: Director of Research Indonesian Survey
Institute (LSI), Indonesia; Meidyatama Suryodiningrat,
Managing Editor, Jakarta Post; James Della-Giacoma,
Senior Advisor, Citizen Participation, National Democratic
Institute (NDI). The discussion will be held at the Woodrow
Wilson International Center for Scholars, 1300 Pennsylvania
Ave, 6th Floor Auditorium. RSVP (acceptances only) by Friday,
July 9, to: asia@wwic.si.edu, or call
202-691-4020.
Democracy
Digest Welcomes Your Cooperation
Democracy
Digest welcomes cooperation from organizations and
individuals in building circulation and in obtaining articles,
speeches, web site addresses, organizational statements and
other materials that may be of interest to readers. Our effort
has just begun. Organizations that have so far agreed to
cooperate include: Aspen
Institute Berlin; the Center for Study of
Islam and Democracy; Council for a Community of
Democracies; FAES Fundacion
(Spain); the Helsinki
Citizens' Assembly(Turkey); the Institute for
Political Studies at the Catholic University of Portugal;
No Peace Without Justice
[Italy]; People in Need
Foundation (Czech Republic); Polish Helsinki Foundation
on Human Rights, Droits et
Democratie (Canada).
We also seek information that may be useful to those
engaged in democracy support activities: dates of conferences
and seminars, the availability of resources, job openings,
etc. Please e-mail us at: demdigest@freedomhouse.org.
We will offer some of this information in the Digest and more
on our web site, demdigest.net, which is currently under
construction.
Democracy Digest is a
weekly summary of analysis and information from the
Transatlantic Democracy Network. For your free e-mail
subscription to Democracy Digest, simply click
"subscribe now" below, then click "send" on the e-mail
tool bar that will appear. No need to fill in the
subject line or add a message--we can simply enter your
e-mail address onto our subscribers' list, where it will
be kept strictly confidential.
Subscribe
Now!(Please
accept our apologies if you receive several copies of
this mailing. We are using several mailing lists for
our initial distributions, so duplication will
inevitably occur.)
|
The Transatlantic Democracy Network
involves North Americans and Europeans in dialogue about
cooperation to support those working for democracy elsewhere
in the world, especially in the Greater Middle East. The
Network is associated with the World Movement for Democracy,
and maintained by a secretariat at Freedom House.
Co-editors of the Digest are Michael Allen
(UK) and Penn Kemble (US.) To comment, get more
information, or send us material that may be of interest to
other readers, please e-mail us at: Michael Allen at mailto:michaela@ned.org or
Penn Kemble at kemble@freedomhouse.org
or demdigest@freedomhouse.org.
Democracy
Digest is published weekly by The Transatlantic
Democracy Network, a cooperative effort of the World Movement
for Democracy (which provides "Information") and Freedom House
(which edits "Issues").
|